今天查询文献，无意中发现《Landscape and urban planning》79 (2007)
401上的主编撤稿声明，指明华东师范大学Liquan Zhang , Jianping Wu , Yu
Zhen, Jiong Shu的论文“A GIS-based gradient analysis of urban
landscape pattern of Shanghai metropolitan area, China”[Landscape
Urban Plan. 69 (2004) 1–16]抄袭而撤稿。尽管作者声明不属于抄袭，并在参
考文献中标注引用了原作者文献，但主编仍认为属于抄袭而撤稿。看来国内学者
对于什么是抄袭需要进一步理解。原文如下：
This article has been retracted.
Reason: This article substantially copies an article by Matthew Luck
and Jianguo Wu, “A gradient analysis of urban landscape pattern: a
case study from the Phoenix metropolitan region, Arizona, USA”
published in Landscape Ecology 17 (4), pp. 327–339, 2002. The authors
Zhang et al. have indicated in response that this does not amount to
plagiarism because the article by Matthew Luck and JianguoWu was cited
in their paper. In my view, the amount copied exceeds the usual
purpose of citation (to refer to prior relevant work) and amounts to
plagiarism.
Jon Rodiek
Editor-in-Chief
Landscape and Urban Planning
(XYS20070930)
◇◇新语丝(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.dropin.org)(xys-reader.org)◇◇ |
发表于 2007-10-1 08:05:23
发表于 2007-10-1 15:42:49
发表于 2007-10-1 17:38:29
